What is the easiest type of eyeliner to use for beginners?

For beginners, pencil eyeliners, especially retractable ones, or felt-tip liquid eyeliner pens are generally the easiest to use. Pencils offer more control and are forgiving for mistakes, while felt-tip pens provide a steady application similar to drawing with a marker.

How do I make my eyeliner last all day without smudging?

To make your eyeliner last all day, start by applying an eye primer to your lids. Choose a long-wear or waterproof formula, especially for liquid or gel liners. You can also lightly set your eyeliner with a matching eyeshadow using a small brush, which helps to lock it in place and prevent smudging.

Can I use eyeliner on my waterline?

Yes, you can use certain eyeliners on your waterline, but it's important to use a product specifically designed or safe for waterline application (often labeled as kohl or designed for inner rim). These formulas are typically softer and more resistant to migration. Always ensure your eyeliner is clean to prevent irritation.

What's the best eyeliner for creating a sharp winged look?

For creating a sharp winged look, liquid eyeliner with a fine brush or felt-tip applicator is ideal. These formulas offer intense pigment and precise control, allowing you to draw crisp lines and perfect your flick. Practice is key to mastering the wing!

How do I choose the right eyeliner color?

While black is a classic for intensity and definition, brown eyeliner offers a softer, more natural look, especially for daytime. Navy or deep plum can make blue and green eyes pop, respectively. Experiment with different colors to see what complements your eye color and desired overall makeup look.

Defining Your Gaze: My Top Picks for the Best Eyeliners for Every Look and Longevity

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

When it comes to eye makeup, a great eyeliner can truly transform your look. Whether you're aiming for a subtle enhancement, a dramatic cat-eye, or a sultry smoky effect, the right eyeliner is your secret weapon for defining your gaze and making your eyes pop. But with so many formulas—liquid, gel, pencil, kohl—and application styles out there, finding your perfect match can feel a little overwhelming. That's why I'm here to cut through the clutter and share my absolute favorite eyeliners. I’ve tested countless options to bring you the best in class for precision, longevity, ease of use, and versatility. Get ready to discover your new go-to for effortlessly stunning eyes!

Defining Your Gaze: My Top Picks for the Best Eyeliners for Every Look and Longevity image 1

Why is a Good Eyeliner Essential for Your Makeup Kit?

Eyeliner isn't just about adding color; it's about shaping, defining, and enhancing. It can make your lashes appear fuller, change the perceived shape of your eyes, and add intensity to any makeup look. A well-applied eyeliner can take you from day to night, from subtle sophistication to bold glamour. Plus, with advances in formulas, many eyeliners offer incredible staying power, resisting smudging, fading, and even water, ensuring your look lasts as long as you do.

What Are the Different Types of Eyeliner and Which One is Right for You?

Liquid Eyeliner: For Precision and Drama

Liquid eyeliners are known for their intense, sharp lines and often come with a brush or a felt-tip applicator. They're perfect for creating winged eyeliner, sharp graphic lines, or a precise cat-eye. They generally offer excellent staying power, especially waterproof liquid eyeliner for sharp lines formulas, and dry to a matte or glossy finish. They can have a slight learning curve, but practice makes perfect!

Gel Eyeliner: For Intense Color and Smooth Application

Gel eyeliners usually come in a pot and are applied with a separate brush. They offer a creamy, smooth application that glides on without tugging. Gel formulas are fantastic for creating a super intense, opaque line, whether you want something sharp or a slightly softer, smudged look before it sets. Many are long-lasting gel eyeliner for intense color and won't budge once dry.

Pencil Eyeliner: For Versatility and Softness

Pencil eyeliners are perhaps the most user-friendly. They come in traditional sharpenable pencils or convenient retractable versions. They're excellent for tightlining, smudging for a smoky effect, or creating a softer, more natural line. While some pencil formulas can be prone to smudging, many newer retractable pencil eyeliners for easy application are designed for long wear.

Kohl Eyeliner: For the Ultimate Smoky Eye

Kohl liners are a specific type of soft, dark pencil eyeliner traditionally used for a very deep, smudged, and intense look. They're perfect for achieving a dramatic smoky eye because of their blendable texture, which allows for effortless diffusion.

Brooke's Top Picks: Best Eyeliners for Every Look and Longevity

Ready to find your new holy grail eyeliner? Here are my absolute favorites that deliver on performance, wear, and ease of use.

1. Precision Powerhouse: Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

For those days when you need your liner to stay put through thick and thin (and humidity!), a high-quality waterproof liquid eyeliner is non-negotiable. I love options with a super fine brush tip for ultimate control.

Pros: Unbeatable longevity, smudge-proof, great for sharp wings, intense black pigment.
Cons: Can be tricky for beginners, requires a good makeup remover.

Defining Your Gaze: My Top Picks for the Best Eyeliners for Every Look and Longevity image 2

2. Creamy & Intense: Long-Lasting Gel Eyeliner

If you love a rich, opaque line but prefer a smoother application than liquid, a gel pot eyeliner is your best friend. Paired with an angled brush, it creates both delicate and bold looks with ease.

Pros: Super pigmented, glides on smoothly, versatile for various looks, often very long-wearing.
Cons: Requires a separate brush, can dry out in the pot if not sealed properly.

3. Effortless Definition: Retractable Pencil Eyeliner

For a quick, easy, and natural-looking definition, a good retractable pencil eyeliner is a must-have. Look for one that's creamy enough to glide without tugging but sets to a long-wearing finish.

Pros: Easy to use, great for tightlining and waterline, travel-friendly, no sharpener needed.
Cons: May not offer the same ultra-sharp precision as liquid, some formulas can smudge more easily.

4. Smoky Eye Master: Kohl Eyeliner

When a truly smudgy, rock-and-roll eye is what you're after, nothing beats a true kohl liner. Its soft texture makes blending a dream.

Pros: Ideal for smoky eyes, very blendable, rich color payoff.
Cons: Less precise for sharp lines, can be prone to smudging if not set.

5. Beginner-Friendly: Felt-Tip Eyeliner Pen

If you're new to liquid liner or just prefer the ease of a pen, a felt-tip eyeliner is a fantastic starting point. The sturdy tip provides more control than a brush.

Pros: Easy to handle, quick application, great for consistent lines.
Cons: Tips can sometimes dry out or fray over time, less flexible for very intricate designs than a brush tip.

How to Choose the Best Eyeliner for Your Needs: A Quick Buying Guide

Consider these factors when picking your next eyeliner:

Your Skill Level: Beginners might prefer pencils or felt-tip pens for easier control, while experienced users can master liquid or gel.
Desired Look: For sharp wings, opt for liquid. For smoky eyes, choose a blendable pencil or kohl. For intense, opaque lines, gel is fantastic.
Longevity Needs: If you need your liner to last all day (or night!) without smudging, look for waterproof, long-wear liquid or gel formulas.
Eye Sensitivity: If you have sensitive eyes, look for ophthalmologist-tested formulas, especially for waterline application.
Color Preference: While black is classic, don't be afraid to experiment with browns, blues, or even metallics to complement your eye color!

Tips for Flawless Eyeliner Application

Prep Your Lids: Always start with a clean, primed eyelid. This helps prevent smudging and improves wear.
Steady Hand: Rest your elbow on a surface, or use your pinky finger to anchor your hand on your cheek for more stability.
Small Strokes: Instead of trying to draw one long line, use small, connected dashes to build up your liner.
Look Down: For liquid liner, looking slightly down into a mirror can help you see your lash line more clearly.
Clean Up: A Q-tip dipped in micellar water or makeup remover is your best friend for cleaning up any mistakes or sharpening your wing.

Defining Your Gaze: My Top Picks for the Best Eyeliners for Every Look and Longevity image 3

With these top picks and tips, you're all set to master your eyeliner game. Experiment with different types and techniques, and don't be afraid to try new looks. Happy lining!